Hero or just influential? (#5)

I knew before reading Malcolm X that Malcolm is a big figure in the African American community especially in Harlem. When I first received his autobiography I expected it to be a book all about his high points in life and all of his successful moments but i was terrible wrong. It exposed Malcolm's true life, depicting the hard life he struggled with.  Malcolm had to consistently overcome obstacles in his life some tougher than others. These included drugs,  stealing, and most importantly he had to overcome his black skin. But are all of these enough to be considered a hero? Well malcolm didn't just overcome these obstacles, he also helped others overcome them as well. Malcolm preached to blacks and also sets a good example to them. He convey that they can achieve anything. But some can argue that Malcolm was not heroic as compared to others of the time. For instance some people believe that he did not withhold up to Martin Luthers accomplishments of that time.  "His legacy did not add up to inspiring one important piece of legislation, leading one important march or actually getting anything done that had objective significance." (Crouch 1). I found an article that expresses ones opinion on Malcolm X. For instance, their opinion on Malcolm X expressed that he was nothing but a "charismatic heckler". They believed that Martin was a greater leader. One of the greatest differences between these two important African Americans is that one accepted violence as a way to convey their point while the other believes in peaceful persuasion. Malcolm X choose the path of violence as a way to convey his message. This might be a reason to consider him less of a hero compared to Martin Luther's peaceful teachings. I believe that Malcolm was an influential person of that time to blacks but i believe he can be a hero to certain people. The definition of hero states "A person, typically a man, who is admired or idealized for courage, outstanding achievements, or noble qualities." (New Oxford American Dictionary) Whether Malcolm falls under that definition depends entirely on who you ask. So it still leaves the question, is he a hero or just an influence African American of the time? Its up to you to decide.